Skip to main content

On Spell Components

Before I begin, I must once again stress that I never or rarely play a spellcasting class. When I do, it is typically a Bard or a Cleric. As such there exist aspects of the typical arcane spellcaster that I do not understand and, given my reluctance to play as one, probably never will understand. One of these things I do not understand are the need for magical components to help a spellcaster facilitate his or her ability to cast spells.

When it comes to magic, I come from the Pulp/Urban Fantasy style of magic. That is, that magic is a natural part the caster, they may need a focus (as in the Dresden Files were words and wands aren’t needed but help the human mind with magic from a psychological perspective) or a sacrifice (as in the Mercy Thompson/Alpha & Omega series’) to draw the magic to the caster.  In my own creation I have used the idea of self-sacrifice in the Blood Witch to act as the agent that facilitates magic.

So it is with the Pulp and Urban Fantasy ideas that I typically draw a logical reason as too why there needs to be components and as such typically don’t require physical components in the games I run. However, they are a part of the rules and as such I need to ask, why?

From a game design perspective I can understand the need for components as they act as a further check and limiting balance to the spellcaster as it requires the search for or purchase of materials to facilitate and manifest his or her casting. From a player or even a reading perspective it is a rather boring and cumbersome mechanic that depending on the referee could make playing the spellcaster a complete chore unless the player creates what would essentially be Batman’s utility belt.

So the question then becomes, if the component mechanic exists to operate as a further check and balance to the spellcasting class, then how could that mechanic be removed without taking away the purpose of the mechanic? I would like to think, however, that components were never meant as a further check and balance but rather as a way to inject some flavor, possible storytelling or even excitement into a situation. Unfortunately, I have rarely seen the use of components as anything but a waste of money on the part of the player and treated as nothing more than an after thought by referees.

To answer my earlier question though, what would work as a check and balance in the place of components? One thing I have been playing with in my daughter’s game is something I’m calling rune-casting.  Rune-casting requires an additional amount of d6 depending on the level of the spell (1d6 for level 1 spells and so on). In game the character must visually create a rune with the motions of their hands, out of game they need to reach a target number on their d6 to successfully cast the spell, even if they rolled their to-hit high enough.  So then the d20 would be the ability to successful manifest the spell, the d6 (rune-casting) would be the effectiveness of the spell brought to mind.

It is still a work in progress and honestly something I stole from a d6 fantasy game was creating but abandoned a few years ago.
So then, how about all of you out there? Do spell components figure into your games or are they a forgotten element? If they are used, how?


Popular posts from this blog

The Robathen's Coin Parts 1 -3

A long time ago I released a short story on drivethrufiction called "The Rabathen's Coin - An Arame Tale" that was meant to be the start of a series staring a mysterious thief named Arame.  Well, five years later and I have sold maybe six copies.  With that in mind I figured I might as well break it up into two or three parts and post in on the blog.

Thoughts are welcome as I am always interested in what others think of my original works.

The stench of rotten fish, sweat, mildewed wood and the ocean rose up from the black waters of the harbor in a visible mist that hung over the free trade city of Wickend adding to the already strong reek of human filth and cheap ale. The setting sun, unable to pierce the vile mist, washed over the crumbling buildings that lined the twisting streets of the Old District. From open doors and windows came the sounds of life, true life, of men laughing and boasting, of women flirting and dealing in their trades. To an outsider, the Old Distr…

[AGE] Iron Horse

I am starting to see a theme evolving here ... and it wasn't even planned.  Enjoy, and feedback is always welcomed!

Magic Item - Arcane Gauntlet

Arcane Gauntlets are small devices of leather and copper fitted to the wearer's primary hand and feature a small, thin gem imbued with pure arcane energies affixed to the palm. As a standard action the wearer of an Arcane Gauntlet may release its energies up to four times in a single encounter safely, and up to eight times if the wearer is willing to endure the burning residual heat from sustained use of the device.  If an Arcane Gauntlet is used to its maximum effect (eight times) it is inoperable until such a time as its wearer takes a long rest.
Arcane Gauntlet- Rare Magical Item - Requires Atunement - Ranged Magical Weapon - Range 60/120ft - One Target, Hit 6 (1d6 + 2) Arcane Damage - Special After 4 uses the Gauntlet inflicts 2 Arcane damage on its wearer during every use in an encounter, on the 8th such use the wearer incurs 1d6 damage from the gauntlet's use.